Double standard when free speech disrupts diversity initiatives. Nlrb, the federal agency that investigates and resolves complaints under. The national labor relations board has declined to assert jurisdiction in the case involving northwestern university football players who receive. Nlrb punts on northwestern university football team george j. In unanimous vote, nlrb rejects northwestern football team. Northwestern and the ncaa have strongly opposed the concept of a players union, arguing that college football players are primarily students, not employees. Explaining what the northwestern college football union.
Nlrb ruling on northwestern football players highlights. The nlrb office of the general counsel concluded that rules in northwesterns football handbook restricting players social media use and other communications about injuries were unlawful. Nlrb punts in northwestern union election hunton employment. Apr 09, 2014 northwestern has officially appealed the national labor relations board decision regarding the employee status of nu football players, the university announced wednesday.
Home nlrb punts in northwestern union election nlrb punts in northwestern union election. Nlrb rejects northwestern football players unionization. Mar 26, 2014 these issues were discussed in detail in nlrb regional director peter sung ohrs opinion, which repeatedly referenced the 50 to 60 hours per week that northwestern university football players must. Aug 20, 2015 in early 2014, we alerted you to a decision by the national labor relations board which approved a union election by northwestern university football players. The docket activity list does not reflect all actions in this case. Nlrb ruling on northwestern football players highlights need. As a result, the board did not determine if the players were employees under the national labor relations act. Nlrb denies northwestern university football players bid to. Aug 19, 2015 on monday, the national labor relations board, or nlrb, put an end note. What does the nlrbs decision mean for northwestern. One year later, nlrb still hasnt ruled on appeal of whether college football players may unionize marc edelman senior contributor opinions expressed by forbes contributors are their own. The university appealed the chicago offices decision to the full national labor relations board in washington, urging the board to reverse the regional directors decision. Some big ten states do not permit collective bargaining at all, and in michigan and ohio, state legislators recently passed laws providing that scholarship athletes at state schools.
As nurses battle with a nationwide staffing shortage, an nlrb decision threatens to limit the ability of nurses to unionize amy albro this note or comment is brought to you for free and open access by northwestern university school of law scholarly commons. Nlrb ruling on graduate students northwestern university. Northwestern had unlawful limits on players, who are employees the memo by the national labor relations boards general counsel is a. Aug 17, 2015 in a 50 ruling monday, the national labor relations board nlrb declined to assert its jurisdiction in a dispute between northwestern university and its football team, effectively ending the. Even if an appeal fails and the nlrb agrees with sung ohr, northwestern can file a lawsuit and hope to get a federal court of appeals to overrule the nlrb. Northwestern university has always regarded its graduate students as students, first and foremost, and has been steadfast in its commitment to support. National labor relations board nlrb influence watch. Implications of northwestern nlrb decision could extend far. The national labor relations board on monday dismissed a petition by northwestern football players who were seeking to unionize, effectively denying their claim that they are university employees. Aug 17, 2015 nlrb declining to recognize northwestern as employees doesnt end the debate since nlrb didnt rule on the merits of the players arguments. Peter sung ohr, the regional director of the national labor relations board, said in a ruling released wednesday, may 26, 2014. Aug 17, 2015 the national labor relations board has declined to assert jurisdiction in the case involving northwestern university football players who receive grantinaid scholarships.
Aug 17, 2015 the national labor relations board has ruled that northwestern football players cannot unionize. Northwestern university football players cannot form a union, the national labor relations board ruled, overturning a march 2014 decision and ending the players bid to change the college sports. Implications of northwestern nlrb decision could extend. Northwestern had argued that a previous case was the proper precedent. Northwestern had unlawful limits on players, who are employees the memo by the national labor relations boards general counsel is a historic step in players rights. For a printerfriendly copy, click here last week, the regional director of the national labor relations boards chicago regional office decided that northwestern football players on grantinaid scholarships are employees under the nlra. Rejects northwestern football players union bid the.
Nlrb office backs union for northwestern football players. In a highly publicized case in which the aaup filed an amicus brief. Apr 24, 2014 nlrb will hear northwestern appeal of employee decision. Read northwesterns brief asking national labor relations board to overturn regional directors ruling on football players unization pdf. This document may require redactions before it can be viewed. National labor relations board northwestern university, employer, and college athletes players association capa, petitioner. This practice is troubling because it fails to respect the free speech rights of the parties and their advisors and runs contrary to regulations and guidance put forth by both the u. The national labor relations board is a federal government agency consisting of a fivemember board appointed by the president with by convention three members of the presidents party and two members of the opposition party and a nominally independent general counsel appointed by the president. Nlrb denies northwestern university football players bid to unionize. In unanimous vote, nlrb rejects northwestern football teams.
Northwestern asks national labor relations board to overturn. Football players at private fbs schools are employees the nlrbs general counsel said athletes are employees according to the national labor relations act. The nlrb has ruled that football players at northwestern must be freely allowed to post on social media, discuss issues of their health and safety, and speak with the media. Jul 03, 2014 in a highly publicized case in which the aaup filed an amicus brief. On january 28, 2014, northwestern university grantinaid scholarship football players filed a petition for a representation election with the national labor. Northwestern university and college athletes players. Last fall, northwestern faced an unfair labor practice charge after a california lawyer contended the football teams rule book encroached on players rights.
How northwestern university has reacted to the nlrbs decision and what may happen. Feb 01, 2017 last fall, northwestern faced an unfair labor practice charge after a california lawyer contended the football teams rule book encroached on players rights. Northwestern players win ruling at nlrb, take next step. Northwestern football players are university employees, nlrb. Nlrb sacks northwestern football players unionizing drive wsj. Directors decision to the national labor relations board in washington. Northwestern university and college athletes players association. On january 28, 2014, northwestern university grantinaid scholarship football players filed a petition for a representation election with the national labor relations board s region office, seeking representation by the college athletes players associationfor the purpose of collective bargaining. Aug 17, 2015 what the nlrbs union decision means for northwestern, ncaa daily file photo by susan du former northwestern quarterback kain colter led the ultimately unsuccessful effort to unionize the nu.
Last week, the regional director of the national labor relations boards chicago regional office decided that northwestern football players on grantinaid scholarships are employees under the nlra. These issues were discussed in detail in nlrb regional director peter sung ohrs opinion, which repeatedly referenced the 50 to 60 hours per week that northwestern university football players must. One year later, nlrb still hasnt ruled on appeal of. Nlrb will hear northwestern appeal of employee decision. Nlrb declines to exercise jurisdiction in northwestern case. The nlrb office of the general counsel concluded that rules in northwesterns football handbook restricting players social media use and other. Northwestern football players cannot form union, nlrb rules.
In amicus briefs filed in july 2014, northwesterns argument was backed by at least eight other private colleges, six republican members of congress and the ncaa. Board to find that northwestern universitys football. Nlrb invites input on northwestern athletes union bid. Mar 27, 2014 northwestern had argued that a previous case was the proper precedent. Northwestern football players lose union bid after labor. What the nlrbs union decision means for northwestern, ncaa daily file photo by susan du former northwestern quarterback kain colter led the ultimately unsuccessful effort to unionize the nu. Northwestern university decision national labor relations board. Subscribe to this free journal for more curated articles on this topic. Northwestern has officially appealed the national labor relations board decision regarding the employee status of nu football players, the university announced wednesday. In early 2014, we alerted you to a decision by the national labor relations board which approved a union election by northwestern university football players. The nlrb said, insofar as the boards decision in brown. Introduction northwestern university, pursuant to section.
In a landmark decision, the nlrb ruled that northwestern university football players with scholarships should be considered employees of the university instead of. In response to the petition, northwestern university argued that the. Nlrb general counsel says private college football players. Introduction northwestern university, pursuant to section 102. How northwestern university has reacted to the nlrbs. Northwestern university employer and case rc1259 college athletes players associationcapa petitioner decision and direction of election upon a petition duly filed under section 9c of the national labor relations act, as amended the act, a hearing was held before a hearing officer of the national labor relations board. Department of education ed and the national labor relations board nlrb. In august 2016, the national labor relations board nlrb ruled that graduate students at private universities are statutory employees within the meaning of the national labor relations act. The unionization of college athletes lsu law digital commons.
Northwestern university national labor relations board. The basis for his decision was that the players provide services for the benefit of the university for compensation and are under the. In a 50 ruling monday, the national labor relations board nlrb declined to assert its jurisdiction in a dispute between northwestern university and its football team, effectively ending the. Northwestern football players cannot form union, nlrb. Nlrbs 2014 northwestern case as a paradigm for future cases inv olving student athletes unionization mobilization efforts, in conjunction with the recent decision in obannon v. Nlrb sacks northwestern football players unionizing drive. Aug 21, 2015 the board noted that, among the fourteen big ten teams, northwestern was the only private school and thus the only program potentially subject to nlrb regulation.
Aug 17, 2015 the national labor relations board on monday threw out a historic ruling that gave northwestern university football players the goahead to form the nations first college athletes union. Rejects northwestern football players union bid, n. Aug 17, 2015 northwestern university football players cannot form a union, the national labor relations board ruled, overturning a march 2014 decision and ending the players bid to change the college sports. After the regional director of the nlrb ruled that certain studentathletes at northwestern university are employees, april 25 has been designated as the date for the election.
Nlrb rules northwestern football players cant form union. Nlrb denies northwestern university football players bid. Nlrb rules northwestern players cant unionize usa today. Federal law gives you the right to form, join or assist a union. Nlrb tosses northwestern university football teams. The twoway last year, a regional national labor relations board director ruled that football players at. To obtain a copy, please file a request through our foia branch. What the nlrbs union decision means for northwestern, ncaa. In a prior decision, the nlrb had rejected a unionization attempt by. The recent decision on graduate students by the national labor relations board nlrb has prompted questions and conversation across campus. Adobe is temporarily offering this capability to provide an alternative to oncampus computer labs. The board, however, explicitly limited its decision to. On monday, the national labor relations board, or nlrb, put an end note. Effective april 3, 2020, adobe is offering all students enrolled in spring quarter courses limitedtime use of the adobe creative cloud suite of software.
Collective bargaining rights to northwestern football players. Earlier this week, the nlrb unanimously dismissed the players representation petition on purely jurisdictional grounds. Bivens abstract the ncaa has established a system through which universities profit tremendously from the athletic careers of student athletes, yet athletes scholarships do not cover the full cost of attendance. Nlrb rejects northwestern football players unionization bid. On january 28, 2014, northwestern university grantinaid scholarship football players filed a petition for a representation election with the national labor relations boards region office, seeking representation by the college athletes players associationfor the purpose of collective bargaining. Nlrb declining to recognize northwestern as employees doesnt end the debate since nlrb didnt rule on the merits of the players arguments. In doing so, the board reversed the finding of a regional director below that the requirements of a valid petition were met, including a finding that the northwestern football players were employees. The national labor relations board is an independent federal agency that protects the rights of private sector employees to join together, with or without a union, to improve their wages and working conditions. To obtain a copy, please file a request through our foia branch related documents. Eligible students will receive an email from adobe, sent to their northwestern email address, with. The northwestern case is far from over, as the university said it will appeal the decision to the full national labor relations board in washington. Northwestern football social media limits unlawful.
Bivens abstract the ncaa has established a system through which universities profit tremendously from the athletic careers of student athletes, yet. Nlrb ruling on northwestern football players highlights need for congressional action on college sports. Northwesterns restrictions on football players ruled unlawful. Northwestern has free speech rights under the nlra to express its opinion about unions, to state facts about unions and unionization and to share with the studentathletes experiences about unions. In a prior decision, the nlrb had rejected a unionization attempt by graduate students working as teaching and research. The national labor relations board on monday threw out a historic ruling that gave northwestern university football players the goahead to form the nations first college athletes union. Northwestern football players are university employees. Aug 17, 2015 nlrb denies northwestern university football players bid to unionize. In a landmark decision, the nlrb ruled that northwestern university football players with scholarships should be considered employees of the university instead of primarily studentathletes.
The national labor relations board dismissed an effort by northwestern university scholarship football players to unionize, a closely watched case that had the potential to reshape college athletics. Northwestern asks national labor relations board to. Alan is both a graduate of northwestern university and a former hearing officer and prosecuting attorney in chicagos regional office of the nlrb. The twoway last year, a regional national labor relations board director ruled that football players at the school could. In amicus briefs filed in july 2014, northwestern s argument was backed by at least eight other private colleges, six republican members of congress and the ncaa. Aug 18, 2015 the national labor relations board on monday dismissed a petition by northwestern football players who were seeking to unionize, effectively denying their claim that they are university employees. Mar 27, 2014 the northwestern case is far from over, as the university said it will appeal the decision to the full national labor relations board in washington. In august, the national labor relations board nlrb or the board unanimously ruled that it lacked jurisdiction to decide whether college football players at northwestern university are employees under the national labor relations act. In 2015 the national labor relations board nlrb or board said no to a union election petition filed by the northwestern university football team.
794 226 846 930 112 1058 1533 114 1172 304 1250 454 919 869 785 362 1559 1199 700 175 1587 902 595 1084 526 1330 96 911 489 768 1486 1028 276 1488 1107 1178 645 419 1080 842 200 550